Elvie VS Willow
Contents
How wearable breast pumps work
Wearable pumps sit inside your bra (rather than hanging off you via tubes) and let you pump without being tethered to an outlet or big external machine. They offer mobility and discretion — which is increasingly important for working moms, moms on the go, or those wanting more flexibility.
However — there are trade-offs: they often cost more than standard pumps, capacity may be lower, battery life may be limited, and fit/macronutrient output can differ vs. hospital-grade pumps.
So when comparing Elvie vs Willow, you’re really comparing two high-end wearable pumps — your choice will depend on your priorities.
Key Specs & Features: Elvie vs Willow
Elvie Pump
Pros
- Flange sizes included: 24mm and 28mm (smaller 21mm available separately).
- It is marketed as very quiet (“silent”) and very discrete under clothing.
- It offers several suction modes (stimulation → expression) and can be app-connected for tracking.
- It uses a 5 oz (≈150 mL) bottle per side (in many markets).
- The Elvie is very compact and designed for discretion (small size, quiet operation).
Cons
- Some reviewers feel the app-tracking or measurement features are not perfectly accurate.
- Higher price tag compared to some alternatives.
- Some users report that fit/positioning is more delicate and if mis-aligned output suffers. For example: > “I had some trouble getting the Elvie properly placed on my nipple a few times … got some painful blisters”
- Because of its compact size, the container capacity is modest and over-filling may be an issue.
Willow Go
Pros
- The Willow line (especially some versions) has a very flexible flange sizing/inserts approach.
- Comes with app functionality (control & track pump) and good capacity options — e.g., 5 oz per side standard, and 7 oz containers available.
- It offers strong suction capability (hospital-grade level). For example up to ~280-295 mmHg suction for Willow Go.
- The Willow Go is also fully wearable (fits inside a bra) and cordless.
Cons
- Battery life / session count may not match top plug-in pumps for heavy use. Some users found three sessions per charge.
- More parts to assemble/clean (depending on version) compared to simpler pumps.
- Because of design, if you bend over or lie down it may be more prone to leakage (unless using the premium “360” version rather than “Go”). For Willow Go: “leak-proof up to 45°” only
- It tends to be bulkier and heavier than Elvie. Users mention the size/weight difference being noticeable.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Elvie Pump | Willow Go |
|---|---|---|
| Discretion & size | Smaller, lighter → win for “discreet”. | Larger/heavier; more noticeable under clothing. |
| Noise level | Very quiet; one of the quietest wearable pumps. | Quiet for what it is, but some users say it’s not quite as silent as Elvie. |
| Suction & “emptying” performance | Good suction (up to ~220 mmHg in older models). Some users say output was slightly lower than traditional pump. | Strong suction (e.g., up to ~280 mmHg) and many users report output comparable to traditional pumps. |
| Capacity / hold-milk | About 5 oz per side in many models. | Standard 5 oz with option for 7 oz containers. |
| Ease of setup & fit | Fewer parts to manage; simpler to position according to some. But fit can be finicky. | Good flange sizing options; but more parts and slightly more assembly may be needed. |
| Mobility / usage scenarios | Great for discreet indoor/outside use; but if you bend/lie down might have limitations (like many wearables). | Very mobile, decent for around-the-house; but if you’ll be bending/lying/active might need the higher “360” version. |
| Price / value | On the higher end of wearable pumps. | Slightly more affordable option (for many markets) in the wearable category. |
| Cleaning / maintenance | Some reviewers say fewer parts than Willow in certain respects. | Some versions have more parts; cleaning/assembly learning curve exists. |
| Best for whom | Moms prioritizing discretion, quiet output, minimal intrusion, maybe pumping on the go and less “heavy” sessions. | Moms who maybe need a bit more suction/output, are okay with somewhat bulkier size, or want more flexibility in container size. |
My Verdict / Which Should You Choose?
It really depends on how and when you plan to pump. Here are scenarios:
- If you are pumping occasionally (say once or twice a day), want maximum discretion (e.g., in a work meeting, public setting), and value a quiet, light pump that can hide under a bra — then Elvie is a very strong choice.
- If you are pumping more frequently (for example, multiple sessions per day), need strong suction (you produce a lot or are exclusively pumping), or you don’t mind a slightly larger size in favour of output and flexibility — then Willow Go (or even upgrade to the Willow 360) might make more sense.
- If you’re bending/lying down often (e.g., nursing/pumping in bed, or very active) then you’ll need to look carefully at leak-proofing. Some reviews say wearable pumps (including both) have limitations when lying flat.
- Budget & insurance considerations are also important: even though these are “premium” pumps, check whether your insurance covers a pump, whether you’ll need accessories/flanges, and what spare part costs are. Many users report that if your pump is your primary device (especially if pumping often) you may want to still have a backup/plug-in pump.
Things to check / questions to ask yourself
When making your decision, think about:
- How often will I pump? Occasional? Daily? Multiple times per day?
- How much milk do I typically express per session? If high, capacity and suction matter.
- Where will I be pumping? Home only? Work meetings? Public/out and about?
- What clothing/bras will I wear? A snug nursing/pumping bra is key for wearables.
- Do I need leak-proofing while lying down or moving a lot?
- What’s my budget? Are there accessories, spare parts, insurance rebates etc?
- Fit/Flange size compatibility — ensure the pump fits your nipple size well. If wrong size, output drops and discomfort arises.
- Cleaning/maintenance comfort — fewer parts or easier cleaning may matter if you’re busy.
FAQs
Can more than one person use the pump?
No — the Elvie Pump is designed as a single-user product.
How long can I pump with Willow in one session?
General advice: 15-20 minutes per side is a typical session length for effective expression.
Does it require the app to work?
You can use the Elvie Pump without the app, but using the “Pump with Elvie” app unlocks its smart features — remote control, live milk-monitoring, session history and firmware updates.
What breast shield sizes come included / how do I know if it fits?
Standard package includes 24 mm and 28 mm shields; a 21 mm option is also available separately. For smaller nipples you can use a nipple cushion. Sizing is based on the width of nipple base.
READ ALSO: How to use Spectra S1?